|
This is a biographical study of one of the most complex African leaders
of the twentieth century colonial era. The book admirably traces the
problems Nkrumah faced as a student and aspiring politician. This African
leader possessed a multifaceted personality and diverse interests which
were reflected his early education in the fields of sociology, education
and philosophy. The various themes of each chapter nicely demonstrate Nkrumah's evolution
from student to African hero. The author's writing style allows for
an appreciation of the interaction between a young Nkrumah and world
leaders during the colonial era. An interesting aspect of the book is Birmingham's tracing of the radical
influences on Nkrumah, including his association with such Pan-Africanists
as C.L.R. James and George Padmore. This was evident in Nkrumah's involvement
in the organization of the Manchester Conference on Pan-Africanism in
1945. Almost two decades later, in 1963, the spirit of Pan-Africanism
would be present as Nkrumah played an instrumental role in the founding
of the Organization of African Unity. To a considerable extent, the author has achieved his aim of providing
an overview of the life of Kwame Nkrumah and the economic and social
forces which were at work at the national and international levels.
The various sections of each chapter depict an image of an African leader
who experienced both adulation and denigration among his people in Ghana.
Whilst the book provides the reader with insight into Nkrumah's life,
the author's analysis of Nkrumah's years of political rule is difficult
to assess. For instance, in the examination of Nkrumah as a national
statesman, Birmingham notes that one of the criticisms of Nkrumah's
rule was that he encouraged a 'personality cult.' The author believes
"the charge was both fair and unfair (p.81)." Also queried,
but never resolved by Birmingham, is the extent to which Nkrumah's rise
to power was attributed to his personal ambitions or the impact of world
events such as the death of Gandhi and apartheid in South Africa: "...
it is hard to judge how far this meteoric ascent was due to his own
driving spirit and how far he simply happened to rise on the crest of
the wave that was then sweeping the colonial world (p.15)." The
work would have been strengthened if the author had taken a stance on
these aspects of in Nkrumah's life and rule. Another shortcoming is that Birmingham has not specifically addressed
the problems encountered by Nkrumah in a separate chapter. Issues such
as the 'preventive detention' act in 1958 to deal with dissident voices,
the Congo crisis of July 1960, and the intervention of the imperial
powers in the late 1960s are only discussed in passing in the chapters
"National Statesman" and African Ideas." Apart from these minor flaws, the book is a colorful biography and
assists the reader in understanding the tribulations and aspirations
of Third World leaders in guiding their countries through the uncertain
transition from colonialism to independence. These leaders were burdened
by pressure to conform to the demands of a realpolitik which often did
not adhere to the realities existing in their countries. Jerome Teelucksingh |