|
Peter J. Schraeder's book offers an excellent introductory course to
Africa. He seeks to rationalize and classify various aspects of contemporary
African politics and society in an interesting and novel manner. This
may seem a logical and practical approach, but surprisingly few studies
have undertaken such an exercise. The lack of a large body of similar
literature makes this book an essential component for anyone interested
in understanding Africa's politics, recent history, myriad of cultures
and its role in world politics. Early on, one realizes that the author
certainly does not share the view that Africa is a "lost continent"
or even a "forgotten" one, but rather a complex and vibrant
"mosaic in transformation." Clearly, it is inevitable that in writing a textbook on African politics
and society a certain degree of generalization is necessary. This is
apparent in the extensive reference to secondary sources, which the
author uses in order to better address the many issues related to the
broad subject of African studies. In this regard, Schraeder incorporates
secondary sources with remarkable skill, especially in the first part
of the book (Sections I-III). In this section, he introduces his study,
classifies the many and diverse theoretical outlooks in African development
studies, gives a historical background to the various schools of political
and economic thought, and outlines the policy implications of "African
ideologies." The author's criticism of these models is quite interesting
and insightful - particularly in Chapters 2 and 3 where he analyzes
the liberal free-market tradition and its failures in its more extreme
forms. Primary sources are less present in the work, since it is not really
intended for an academically trained audience. Rather, the book is oriented
towards the general public and undergraduate students. Schraeder does
not provide equal depth on all African countries, for example, he does
not discuss North African nations in any detail. However, he offers
meticulous references to further sources and reading material at the
conclusion of each chapter, and provides a thorough bibliography. The second part of the book (Sections IV-VI) is more open to criticism,
and deals with socio-cultural issues (Section IV), governance (Section
V) and international relations (Section VI). In this context, the author
naturally concentrates on his own ideas and interpretations regarding
Africa. While the inclusion of the author's opinions makes these sections
interesting for the reader, there are some classifications that are
debatable. For example, when the author maps out the various "African
ideologies" (p. 170) he treats Zimbabwe, Sudan, Senegal, etc. as
capitalist countries - or "capitalist variations" - whereas
he treats countries such as Libya, or Ghana as "socialist variations".
Of course, the method used in such a classification directly affects
the outcome of the study. It is not clear what methodology is being
applied in order to differentiate between the various countries and
the classification thus appears rather arbitrary. Once the classification
is made, the author makes a comparison between the development performance
of the different African ideologies. He concludes that "capitalist"
African countries did better in economic growth, autonomy from foreign
control, human rights, and political participation (pp. 188-9), but
the weak methodological premise makes this conclusion less than persuasive.
Indeed, Schraeder places the Democratic Republic of Congo, Kenya, Nigeria,
Sierra Leone and Chad among the "capitalist variation" category,
together with more well-run countries such as Botswana or Mali. This
begs the question: how can it be possible that countries which differ
so much in terms of "good" governance fit into the same category? In some sections of the book, there is a tendency to oversimplify terms
and ideas, such as his treatment and discussion of "governance,
for example. However, a protracted debate on the notion of governance
in Africa would limit the book's wide appeal and place it within a scholarly
niche. As stated earlier, the aim of the author is to make African studies
accessible and fascinating to as many people as possible. From this
perspective, Schraeder's decision to include a chapter on African novelists,
filmmakers and other artists (Chapter 9) in relation to politics is
inspired. In fact, even the author's discussion on governance, avoids
a dry, theoretical approach and concentrates instead on more lively
topics like the struggle between the State and the civil society and
the central role of the military elite in many African countries. Overall, the book achieves the dual goal of being easy to read while
providing an informative and accessible discussion on the current state
of Africa. It attempts to demonstrate that Africa does not always match
our preconceived ideas and that it is in fact, a complex and multifaceted
continent. Schraeder describes an Africa that counts internationally
and that is conscious of its role in world politics. The author encourages
the reader to rethink and reject the various biases that he/she may
have held about Africa. In short, Schraeder has written an engaging
and interesting book; a must-read for those new to African studies. Stefano Bellucci |