|
Health related behavior is defined broadly to encompass all activities
that have a significant effect on health care utilization and health
care delivery (including culture, social behavior, expenditures, and
health policies). This Oxfam publication is based on material originally
published in Development and Health, a journal devoted to health
and developmental issues. Practitioners and policy makers involved in health promotion or interested
in the study of health behavior will find this book very helpful as
it provides useful information about the pitfalls and constraints to
be taken into account in health promotion policies, especially in developing
societies. At the same time, the book offers the reader sufficient information
about the social, cultural, and behavioral determinants of the health
of women in developing societies. Most importantly, the book presents
several aspects of health as seen through the lens of the social and
health worker. The book begins with a survey of the methodological issues relevant
to the study of women's health and moves to a discussion of the factors
that constrain or inhibit health utilization. Throughout the book, the
articles draw the readers attention to how macro level issues
(such as Structural Adjustment Policies) can affect the cost of care
as well as the utilization of health care services among poor women.
Another interesting aspect of the book is its concern with mental and
psychosocial health issues, a subject infrequently discussed in the
discourse about health care in developing societies. For instance, in
the article "The Psychosocial Effects of Conflict in the Third
World", Derek Summerfield asks a few interesting questions about
the relationship between population processes such as migration (forced
or voluntary) and mental health. What are the health consequences of
post-traumatic stress syndrome on people from the third world? How have
the various wars and conflicts prevalent in the developing world for
the past three decades affected the lives of these people? Similar issues
are articulated by Patel et al. who argue that mental health issues
are genuine areas for research, and for intervention programs. Sundari Ravindrans chapter on "Methodological Issues in
Womens Health Research" provides a framework that considers
the interaction between social, economic, political, and cultural factors
in applied health status research, and in health utilization. Anne LaFonds piece, "Deterrents to Immunization in Somalia:
A Mothers Attitudes", is an important contribution to the
literature on child survivorship. The question asked here revolves around
the best way to provide intervention strategies aimed at the health
needs of young children. In this regard, LaFond draws on her experience
in Somalia to alert program administrators in the developing world of
the need to consider the structural and social constraints in existence
in these societies since they can impede the acceptance of new ideas/innovations. One of the interesting chapters in the book is Betsy Hartmans
"Population Control in the New World Order." Hartman examines
the population control movement and how its activities can affect basic
human rights, especially the rights of women. She argues interestingly
that with the end of the Cold War, there has been a shift in ideology
from military expenditures to population control. The latter, she argues,
has been refurbished and polished with feminist and environmental themes
and marketed with the latest means of communication. In the North, the
current emphasis is on immigration control, while in the South, efforts
are geared to using what she refers to as "double-speak" (choice,
female empowerment, environmental concerns, etc.) in discussing the
population question in the developing world. Yet, in their attempts
to reduce high birth rates in the developing world, Hartman argues that
the advocates of population control have failed to consider the factors
that determine the demand for children in the first place: increased
infant mortality levels, the labor needs of agrarian societies, as well
as the limited economic opportunities in these societies. While Hartman
does not negate the need for contraception, she argues that the way
planning is implemented undermines the health systems and targets women
unfairly. Thus, to her, blaming poverty and environmental degradation,
a typical Malthusian conception of population vis-à-vis development,
obscures the real cause of the global population crisis--the inequities
inherent in the socio-economic systems whereby resources are concentrated
in the hands of a few. The impact of AIDS is considered from the perspectives of changing
gender and social relations. In "Widowhood and Orphans: Property
Disputes in Rakai District, Uganda", Chris Roys informs the reader
of some of the consequences of Africas AIDS epidemic in relation
to property and inheritance rights. While the issue of property rights
and succession is one of the social problems facing many African societies,
Roys argues that in the case of Rakai, the problems have been accentuated
by the AIDS virus in that region of Uganda. In part, the problems derive
from the early morbidity and mortality linked to the AIDS epidemic.
Yet Roys suggests that there is the need to look at the main cause of
the conflict between family members on property rights. The clan system,
which is patrilineal and makes it difficult for women to inherit property,
is seen as at the root of the "inheritance debacle" in Rakai.
The empowerment of women, especially economic self sufficiency and changes
in the laws of inheritance, are expected to help women in this regard.
Hillary Hughes's article on "Evaluating HIV/AIDS Programs"
examines ways to assess a successful intervention program. She argues
that a successful program often depends on the level of organization
already in existence in the community as well as the involvement of
the community. In this way, not only would knowledge of the existence
of the disease be beneficial, but it would encourage "local content"
and participation. The list of references and the annotated bibliography is extensive
and should be useful for a wide range of people--absolute beginners,
health care workers involved in capacity building, and people with experience
but little formal training in health promotion planning or evaluation.
I would not hesitate in recommending this book to anybody with an interest
in health evaluation and program planning in the developing world. Baffour Takyi |